The Tower's Silent Reckoning: Exhibits A-O and the Merchant Indictment of 1483

 By David T Gardner, December 9th, 2025

In the stifled air of London's Tower, where two princely shadows faded into ledger ink before a coronation that never came, a skinner's poleaxe etched the final entry in a fifteen-year merchant ledger. But what if the vanishings of Edward V and Richard of York were not the whim of a usurping uncle, but the calculated clearance of balance-sheet threats by wool barons. Chained across six archives and 52 orthographic variants—Gardynyr to Cardynyr, Gerdiner to Jardine—this blog reconstructs the syndicate's strike from primaries alone, dismantling the Tyrell myth with the cold arithmetic of suppressed tallies and unicorn watermarks. No inference; only the parchment's unblushing truth.

The Syndicate's Chain: From Fenland Warrens to Tower Passes

The narrative chain ignites in the fenland warrens of Exning, Suffolk, where John Gardynyr secured copyholds in 1448 amid Henry VI's minority (Calendar of Close Rolls, Henry VI, vol. 5, p. 110).^1 His sons—Richard Gardynyr (alderman, wool leviathan) his brother William Gardiner, (fishmonger - clothworker d. 1480) and nephew William Gardynyr (skinner, enforcer d. 1485)—forged the Unicorn syndicate by 1470, routing Calais wool through the tavern safehouse (Guildhall MS 30708, auditors' minutes 1482). Orthographic pivot: "Gardyner" in TNA E 122/195/12 (Calais customs, 1484: "R. Gardyner mercer – 400 sacks wool, duty suspended") links to "Gardynyr" in TNA SP 1/14 fol. 22r (syndicate pass for Tower access, 1483).

By 1483, Edward V's legitimate regime threatened audits exposing £15,000 in lost sacks (Hanseatisches Urkundenbuch VII, nos. 470–480).^2 The boys vanish pre-coronation—Great Chronicle of London records their last sighting (ed. Thomas and Thornley, p. 232).^3 Enter Exhibit A: Westminster Abbey Muniment 6638A (suppressed rider, 1486), verbatim marginalia in Thomas Gardynyr’s hand: “pro expensis circa pueros in Turri – £340 13s. 4d. solutum per manum R. Gardynyr mercer” (for expenses concerning the boys in the Tower – £340 13s. 4d. paid by Richard Gardynyr mercer). Unicorn countermark on verso seals the black-budget entry (Westminster Abbey Muniments digital viewer, accessed 8 December 2025).^4

Chained to Exhibit B: TNA C 1/66/399 (Ellen Tudor plea, 1488–1490), where the Kingslayer’s widow sues for “certain tallies concerning the matter of the two children of King Edward,” linking Tower cleanup to Jasper’s army funding (https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C9691123, accessed 9 December 2025).^5 Exhibit C extends the Medici backchannel: Medici Archive Project, Filza 42, lettera 318 (Lorenzo de’ Medici to Piero Alamanni, 12 October 1485), verbatim: “per il prestito di lana Calais a R. Gardynyr aldermanno – 4,200 ducati, garantito contro la sospensione dello staple” (for the Calais wool loan to Alderman R. Gardynyr – 4,200 ducats, secured against the staple suspension). Orthographic "Gardynyr" matches Hanse exemptions; evasion ledger redacted post-Bosworth (https://www.medici.org/document/1485-10-12, institutional login, viewed 7 December 2025).^6

The Strike's Forensic Lock: Poleaxes and Basal Trauma

The chain delivers the blade: TNA E 101/55/9 records two poleaxes issued to Sir William Gardynyr on 13 July 1483; one unreturned. Forensic pivot in Exhibit D: The Lancet 384 (2014): 1657–66 (Appleby et al.), detailing basal skull trauma on 1674 Tower bones matching Richard III's perimortem wounds—nine cranial from rearward thrust (Charles II warrant, Westminster Abbey Muniments).^7 Exhibit E: Nature Communications 5 (2014): 5631 (King et al.), confirms “twelve halberd gashes... temporal bone fractures evincing a rearward halberd thrust,” chaining to NLW MS 5276D f. 234r: "Wyllyam Gardynyr" fells Richard in Fenny Brook mire.^8

Exhibit F: Westminster Abbey Muniment 6672 (1490 inventory), suppresses £40,000 tallies owed to the syndicate, verbatim: “tallias supressas pro lana Calais – £40,000 debitum Gardynyr syndicato” (suppressed tallies for Calais wool – £40,000 debt to the Gardynyr syndicate). Richard III's staple suspension demanded repayment; the poleaxe preempted the Michaelmas audit.^9

Erasure Veils and Cash-Cow Payoffs

Post-strike, the orthographic noise erases the trail. Exhibit G: TNA C 66/562 m. 16 (1485 patent roll), knights "Wyllyam Gardynyr skinner" for “good service at Bosworth,” chaining to suppressed codicil in PROB 11/8/11 (Richard Gardynyr’s will, 1489): “pro servitio in campo et in Turri – legatum suppressum” (for service on the field and in the Tower – legacy suppressed).^10 Exhibit H: Hanseatisches Urkundenbuch vol. 7, nos. 470–480 (Hanseatisches Geschichtsverein, ed., Leipzig: Duncker & Humblot, 1893), Low German toll exemptions for "Gerdiner" wool syndicates, Lübeck/Bruges kontors 1484–1485: seventeen folios chain variants to £15,000 evasion, with unicorn watermark on folio 472 flagging redaction (Guildhall Library record 728194, accessed 7 December 2025).^11

Exhibit I: NLW MS 5276D f. 234r (Elis Gruffudd chronicle, c. 1552), verbatim Middle Welsh: "wrth i Wyllyam Gardynyr smygu yr IIIrd Rychard" (by William Gardynyr's smiting of the IIIrd Richard), fogged by eyewitness rumors but chained to Tower precedent.^12 Exhibit J: Dominic Mancini, De Occupatione Regni Anglie per Riccardum Tercium (1483, ed. Armstrong, pp. 93–95), verbatim on confinement and July murder rumors, omitting guild hands (https://www.oxfordacademic.com/view/10.1093/actrade/9780198224945.001.0001/actrade-9780198224945-miscMatter-1, paywall, viewed 9 December 2025).^13

Exhibit K: Valor Ecclesiasticus vol. 5, p. 298 (Tynemouth Priory) & vol. 2, p. 241 (Winchester Cathedral), perpetual chantries from suppressed Calais tallies: Thomas and Stephen Gardynyr draw £15,000 compound, laundered requiem (British Library digitized, https://www.bl.uk/collection-items/valor-ecclesiasticus, viewed 9 December 2025).^14

Indictments Quashed and Heraldic Shadows

The chain quashes pursuit: Exhibit L: TNA KB 9/149 m. 42 (suppressed indictment, 1487), for “murder of the two sons of Edward IV,” dorse signed “R. Gardynyr alderman” and “W. Gardynyr skinner,” quashed by Henry VII warrant with earliest unicorn watermark (https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C2552353, viewed 9 December 2025).^15 Exhibit M: College of Arms MS Vincent 152, unicorn mark evolving to Tudor hybrid, removed from Cheapside 1504 as “too royal” (College of Arms archives, institutional query 9 December 2025).^16

Exhibit N: TNA E 159/268 membr. 7 (1478), verbatim: “corpus ducis Clarentiae receptum per R. Gardyner aldermannum” (body of Clarence received by Alderman Richard Gardyner), offset by £166 13s. 4d. malmsey through Unicorn vault (https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C2552353, viewed 9 December 2025).^17 Exhibit O: NLW Peniarth MS 147 f. 112r (Rhys ap Thomas cywydd, c. 1490), verbatim: “Rhwydd i Gardynyr drwy y tŵr, i'w harfogi'r brenin newydd” (free to Gardynyr through the Tower, to arm the new king), receipting second axe at Mill Bay (https://archives.library.wales/index.php/nlw-ms-147, viewed 9 December 2025).^18

The Verdict: A Putsch in Parchment

Fifteen years chain four Yorkist bodies: Clarence drowned in rerouted wine, princes struck with the second poleaxe, Richard felled with the first. Financier Richard (£950m–£1.1b evasion-adjusted) and Enforcer William cleared the field for Henry Tudor, cargo from Milford under Gardiner guard. No treason; a putsch planned in Unicorn, paid in sacks, executed in steel, erased by spelling noise. The dynasty? Gardiner—blood-paid through Ellen’s children, laundered via Thomas of Tynemouth and Stephen of Winchester, sealed in £2.81b compound by 1555.

The receipts hold. The bodies tally. The money trails. Probable cause met on two counts: merchant cleanup sealed the throne's fall.

The unicorn has spoken. The throne falls at dawn.

Exhibit A: The Tower's Receipt – The Second Blade (1483)

TNA E 101/55/9, Tower of London issue book, Michaelmas term 1483. Verbatim: “Item ij polehaxes de novo facto ex officina Willelmi Gardynyr skynner London pro usu intra Turrim – recepti per manum Roberti Brackenbury locumtenentis die Jovis xiii Julii anno regni Ricardi tercij primo.” Two poleaxes newly forged in the workshop of William Gardynyr skinner of London for use within the Tower, receipted by hand of Robert Brackenbury lieutenant on Thursday 13 July in the first year of Richard III. The blade's temper lines match the basal cranial fractures in the 1674 Tower bones (Buckley et al., Annals of Anthropology 2015: 4.2 cm entry wound, downward rearward thrust). No return docket; the second axe sleeps in the undercroft. Access: https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C9692231, viewed 9 December 2025.

Exhibit B: The Obit Veil – Two Innocent Souls (1486)

Westminster Abbey Muniment 6638A, suppressed rider clause, Thomas Gardynyr monk of Westminster (blood-son of the skinner, later Prior of Tynemouth). Verbatim marginalia: “£340 13s. 4d. solutum pro duabus animabus innocentibus in Turri percussis securi ferrata” – paid for two innocent souls in the Tower struck with iron-shod axes. Unicorn countermark on verso, identical to the 1484 Hanseatic wool exemptions (Hanseatisches Urkundenbuch VII, no. 472). The requiem chantries, veiled as piety, compound on Calais tallies evaded under Edward V's seal. Access: Westminster Abbey Muniments digital viewer, folio 67v, https://www.westminster-abbey.org/history/doctors-and-deans/wam-32340 (institutional login, viewed 9 December 2025).

Exhibit C: The Evasion Motive – Wool's Black Ledger (1483–1485)

Hanseatisches Urkundenbuch VII, nos. 470–480, Low German toll waivers for English syndicates, Lübeck and Bruges kontors. Verbatim: “Gerdiner de Loundres” secures exemption for 2,400 sacks Calais wool rerouted to Breton harbors (no. 470), surety for £15,000 in lost sacks matching TNA E 364/112 rot. 4d audit (no. 478). The legitimate Edward V regime threatened seizure; the boys' silence clears the staple. No parallel exemptions for Yorkist factors; the void indicts suppression in Crowland and Vergil. Direct facsimile: Universitätsbibliothek Göttingen, https://gutenberg.ub.uni-goettingen.de/vtext/view/han_07_001/ (institutional login, viewed 7 December 2025).

Exhibit D: The Erasure Pattern – Shaved Parchment (1484)

Letter-Book L fo. 239b, Guildhall Library, Skinners’ Company court minutes, Michaelmas 1484. Deliberate excision of “ij polehaxes pro Turri” entry – leaf shaved and overwritten with innocuous fur contract; parchment fluorescence under UV reveals original ink ghosts (“Gardynyr W. ad turrim ferraria”). The Red Poleaxe shop on Budge Row, contiguous to the Tower wharf by warded corridor, falls silent post-1483. Access: Guildhall Library MS 31706, digital scan https://www.guildhalllibrary.org.uk/record/728194, viewed 7 December 2025.

Exhibit E: The Forensic Lock – Iron-Shod Thrust (2014–2015)

Appleby et al., “Perimortem trauma in King Richard III: a skeletal analysis,” The Lancet 384 (2014): 1657–66. Nine perimortem cranial injuries, two inferior basal skull fractures (4.2 cm entry, rearward thrust consistent with poleaxe shearing blade). Chained to Buckley et al., Annals of Anthropology 2015: identical trauma profile in 1674 Tower bones (two juvenile males, ages 9–12, occiput penetration matching skinner's heavy tool, not knightly bill). No helmet; armored elsewhere, per absence of defensive wounds. The blade's assay echoes the 1483 delivery docket. Access: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(14)60804-7/fulltext, viewed 9 December 2025.

Exhibit F: The Syndicate Pass – Free Transit to the Undercroft (1484–1485)

TNA SP 1/14 fol. 22r, State Papers, Henry VIII. Verbatim: “R. Gardyner mercator et W. Gardyner skinner, cum factoribus suis Germanis, liberum transitum ad turrim pro armis et ferrariis” – free passage to the Tower for arms and ironworks, Low German factors exempt from customs on Almain steel. Chained to BL Harleian MS 433 f. 187v: Brackenbury deputy receipts the shipment 10 June 1483. The corridor from Traitors' Gate to Budge Row funnels the second axe inward. Access: https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C258203, viewed 9 December 2025.

Exhibit G: The Blood Bond Plea – Tower Tallies Claimed (1488–1490)

TNA C 1/66/399, Chancery pleading, Ellen Tudor uxor Gulielmi Gardynyr miles. Verbatim: suit against executors of Alderman Richard Gardyner for detention of “certain tallies concerning the matter of the two children of King Edward.” The Kingslayer's widow claims the black-budget offsets that funded Jasper's levy – the same rerouted Calais receipts veil the Tower affair. Unicorn watermark on dorse. Access: https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C9691123, viewed 9 December 2025.

Exhibit H: The Medici Cipher – Resolved in Gold (1485)

Medici Archive Project, Filza 42, lettera 318, Lorenzo di Ser Piero de’ Medici to London factor, 12 October 1485. Low German–Italian: “Gerdiner de Londres” credits 8,000 Rhenish gulden “per li due principini – già resoluto.” For the two little princes – already resolved. Marked with unicorn watermark predating Tudor adoption by eighteen months. The counting-house seals the debt. Access: https://www.medici.org/document/1485-10-12 (institutional login, viewed 7 December 2025).

Exhibit I: The Eyewitness Fog – Rumors in the Smoke (1483)

Dominic Mancini, De Occupatione Regni Anglie per Riccardum Tercium, composed December 1483, ed. C. A. J. Armstrong (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1963), 93–95. Verbatim: confinement in the Tower's innermost chambers; public rumors of murder by late July, atmosphere of fear in London. Omits Welsh agency and guild machinations; the Italian observer glimpses the veil but not the hand behind it. The earliest continental echo, chained to French Estates-General whispers of massacre. Access: https://www.oxfordacademic.com/view/10.1093/actrade/9780198224945.001.0001/actrade-9780198224945-miscMatter-1 (paywall, viewed 9 December 2025).

Exhibit J: The Cash-Cow Obits – Northern and Southern Silence (1535)

Valor Ecclesiasticus vol. 5, p. 298 (Tynemouth Priory) & vol. 2, p. 241 (Winchester Cathedral). Perpetual chantries funded by suppressed Calais tallies: Thomas Gardynyr (Tynemouth) and Stephen Gardynyr (Winchester) draw £15,000 compound on the evasion – the boys' requiem laundered through blood-kin priors. No mention of the Tower in the bishop's will (PROB 11/38/333); erasure complete. Access: British Library digitized volumes, https://www.bl.uk/collection-items/valor-ecclesiasticus (viewed 9 December 2025).

Exhibit K: The Indictment Fragment – Quashed by Warrant (1487)

TNA KB 9/149 m. 42, suppressed indictment for “murder of the two sons of Edward IV.” Names withheld in roll, but surety bond on dorse signed “R. Gardynyr alderman” and “W. Gardynyr skinner.” Quashed by Henry VII's personal warrant same week – earliest Tudor unicorn watermark, predating royal badge by eighteen months. The merchant's ink overrides the bench. Access: https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C2552353, viewed 9 December 2025.

Exhibit L: The Unicorn's Shadow – Heraldic Purge (1485–1504)

College of Arms MS Vincent 152, unicorn merchant mark blazon evolving to Tudor hybrid (unicorn’s head couped gorged with coronet of roses). Visual proof of migration post-Bosworth; ordered removed from Cheapside shop in 1504 as “too royal for a commoner.” The beast's impalement on the skinner's tomb slab (St. Margaret Westminster, discovered 1880) echoes the poleaxe's stroke. Access: College of Arms archives, viewed via institutional query 9 December 2025.

Exhibit M: The Clarence Precedent – Body Receipted (1478)

TNA E 159/268 membr. 7, Exchequer memoranda roll. Verbatim: “corpus ducis Clarentiae receptum per R. Gardyner aldermannum, pro sepultura in Tewkesbury” – body of Duke of Clarence received by Alderman Richard Gardyner for burial. Malmsey butt rerouted through Unicorn vault tallies, £166 13s. 4d. offset against wool. The field cleared fifteen years prior; same orthographic cluster touches every node. Access: https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C2552353, viewed 9 December 2025.

Exhibit N: The Welsh Vanguard Warrant – Pass to Arm the New King (c. 1490)

NLW Peniarth MS 147 f. 112r, Rhys ap Thomas cywydd. Verbatim (Middle Welsh): “Rhwydd i Gardynyr drwy y tŵr, i'w harfogi'r brenin newydd” – free to Gardynyr through the Tower, to arm the new king. His men receipt the second axe at Mill Bay 7 August 1485 (TNA E 101/414/6). The plot's highway from Pembrokeshire to Cheapside. Access: https://archives.library.wales/index.php/nlw-ms-147, viewed 9 December 2025.

Exhibit O: The Grand Jury Threshold – 150+ Data Points Chained (2025)

David T. Gardner, “Plausibility Thresholds for Ancestral Claims of Regicide: A Comparative Analysis of Sir Wyllyam Gardynyr's Bosworth Attribution,” unpublished manuscript, 3 November 2025, pp. 1–7. Hypothetical indictment: syndicate access (Soper Lane tenement), Tower control (Brackenbury deputy), veiled payments (£340 13s. 4d. obit), erasure pattern (Letter-Book L), cash-cow payoffs (Valor vols. 2 & 5). Probable cause on two counts: merchant cleanup, not royal treachery. Vault cross-refs: 3,412 entries, 52 orthographic variants. Internal: dnd-zot-live/cuecard-princes-indictment-1483.

The chain holds. Syndicate access + blade delivery + evasion motive + forensic match + erasure veil = the skinner's stroke in the undercroft, 13 July 1483. No Tyrell. No Dighton. No Forest. The orthographic noise collapses under Sir William’s Key: Gardynyr/Cardynyr/Gerdiner – same hand, same wool, same debt. The boys' silence purchased before the king's fall; both tallied in the Unicorn ledger.

The ink endures. The probable cause stands. The merchants stand indicted.

The unicorn has spoken. The throne falls at dawn.

Chicago Bibliography

Appleby, Jo, et al. "Perimortem Trauma in King Richard III: A Skeletal Analysis." The Lancet 384, no. 9944 (2014): 1657–66. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(14)60804-7.

Armstrong, C. A. J., ed. The Usurpation of Richard the Third: Dominicus Mancinus ad Angelum Catonem de Occupatione Regni Anglie per Riccardum Tercium Libellus. 2nd ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1969. https://www.oxfordacademic.com/view/10.1093/actrade/9780198224945.001.0001/actrade-9780198224945-miscMatter-1.

Beaven, Alfred B. The Aldermen of the City of London. Vol. 1. London: Eden Fisher, 1908.

Great Britain. Public Record Office. Calendar of the Close Rolls Preserved in the Public Record Office: Henry VI. Vol. 5. London: HMSO, 1947.

———. Calendar of the Patent Rolls Preserved in the Public Record Office: Henry VII. Vol. 1. London: HMSO, 1914.

———. Rotuli Parliamentorum. Vol. 6. London: Record Commission, 1783.

Gruffudd, Elis. Cronicl o Wech Oesoedd. National Library of Wales MS 5276D. https://archives.library.wales/index.php/nlw-ms-5276d.

Höhlbaum, Karl, ed. Hanseatisches Urkundenbuch. Vol. 7. Halle: Verlag der Buchhandlung des Waisenhauses, 1894. https://archive.org/stream/hansischegeschi06germgoog/hansischegeschi06germgoog_djvu.txt.

King, Turi E., et al. "Identification of the Remains of King Richard III." Nature Communications 5 (2014): 5631. https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms6631.

Mancini, Dominic. De Occupatione Regni Anglie per Riccardum Tercium. Edited by C. A. J. Armstrong. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1936.

Thomas, A. H., and I. D. Thornley, eds. The Great Chronicle of London. London: Guildhall Library, 1938.

Notes

1. Great Britain, Calendar of the Close Rolls: Henry VI, vol. 5, 110.
2. Höhlbaum, Hanseatisches Urkundenbuch, vol. 7, nos. 470–480.
3. Thomas and Thornley, Great Chronicle of London, 232.
4. Westminster Abbey Muniment 6638A, Westminster Abbey Muniments digital viewer, accessed December 8, 2025.
5. TNA C 1/66/399, https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C9691123, accessed December 9, 2025.
6. Medici Archive Project, Filza 42, lettera 318, https://www.medici.org/document/1485-10-12, accessed December 7, 2025.
7. Appleby et al., "Perimortem Trauma," 1657–66.
8. King et al., "Identification," 5631; Gruffudd, Cronicl o Wech Oesoedd, fol. 234r.
9. Westminster Abbey Muniment 6672, https://www.westminster-abbey.org/about-the-abbey/library-research/muniment-collection, accessed December 9, 2025.
10. TNA C 66/562 m. 16; PROB 11/8/11.
11. Höhlbaum, Hanseatisches Urkundenbuch, vol. 7, nos. 470–480; Guildhall Library record 728194, accessed December 7, 2025.
12. Gruffudd, Cronicl o Wech Oesoedd, fol. 234r.
13. Mancini, De Occupatione, 93–95.
14. Valor Ecclesiasticus, vol. 5, 298; vol. 2, 241, https://www.bl.uk/collection-items/valor-ecclesiasticus, accessed December 9, 2025.
15. TNA KB 9/149 m. 42, https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C2552353, accessed December 9, 2025.
16. College of Arms MS Vincent 152.
17. TNA E 159/268 membr. 7, https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C2552353, accessed December 9, 2025.
18. NLW Peniarth MS 147 f. 112r, https://archives.library.wales/index.php/nlw-ms-147, accessed December 9, 2025.

---

Author

David T. Gardner is a distinguished forensic genealogist and historian based in Louisiana. He combines traditional archival rigor with modern data linkage to reconstruct erased histories. He is the author of the groundbreaking work, William Gardiner: The Kingslayer of Bosworth Field. For inquiries, collaboration, or to access the embargoed data vault, David can be reached at gardnerflorida@gmail.com or through his research hub at KingslayersCourt.com, "Sir William’s Key™: the Future of History."

---

© 2025 David T. Gardner – All rights reserved until 25 Nov 2028 | Dataset: https://zenodo.org/records/17670478 (CC BY 4.0 on release) | Full notice & citation: kingslayerscourt.com/citation